Companies Go to New Depths for Ocean Plastic in Recycling Push – The Wall Street Journal

Companies seeking to cut plastic use are tapping a vast source of raw materials: ocean garbage.

Coca-Cola Co. recently unveiled a bottle made in part of recycled marine litter. Interface Inc., the world’s biggest maker of carpet tiles, is weaving rugs with yarns produced from discarded fishing nets. Startups are raising funds to fish for plastics and make new products.

“There’s value in this, and if you do it right, it doesn’t have to cost,” said Nigel Stansfield, Atlanta-based Interface’s president for Europe, Africa, Asia and Australia.

Phytoextractum Buy Kratom Banner

Striking that balance presents a challenge for companies striving to do good, earn money and avoid accusations of greenwashing, or making bogus environmental claims.

Douglas Rader, chief oceans scientist at the nonprofit Environmental Defense Fund, welcomed all the initiatives, even though they only scratch the surface. “The problem is massive in its scale,” he said.

Trash Surge

Unabated production is boosting plastic waste, with limited recycling compounding challenges to curb environmental damage.

Global plastic production

Global plastic production by disposal

method, 2016

Process

losses

Incinerated

 million metric tons

Landfills 32%

In use*

22

Unmanaged

dumps or leaks 15

Recycled

Global plastic production

Global plastic production

by disposal method, 2016

Process

losses

 million metric tons

Incinerated

Landfills 32%

In use*

22

Unmanaged

dumps or leaks

15

Recycled

Global plastic production

Global plastic production by disposal

method, 2016

Process

losses

Incinerated

 million metric tons

Landfills 32%

In use*

22

Unmanaged

dumps or leaks 15

Recycled

Global plastic production

 million metric tons

Global plastic production

by disposal method, 2016

Process

losses

Incinerated

Landfills 32%

In use*

22

Unmanaged

dumps or leaks 15

Recycled

*Items with a lifespan of more than a year will likely end up as waste in later years.

Sources: ‘Production, use, and fate of all plastics ever made’ Roland Geyer, Jenna R. Jambeck, Kara Lavender Law (production); McKinsey& Co. (production and waste)

The weight of ocean plastic will rival that of fish by 2050, according to the U.K.-based Ellen MacArthur Foundation. Each year, roughly eight million tons of plastic leak into the ocean—the equivalent of a garbage truck’s worth of trash each minute—because of poor or lacking waste-management systems. That amounts to about $10 billion worth of packaging materials based on market prices, the nonprofit’s calculations show.

But snagging plastic from oceans and reusing it are difficult. Extended exposure to saltwater degrades plastic, making it more expensive to recycle, said Al Carey, executive chairman of North Carolina-based fiber company Unifi Inc.

The Ocean Cleanup, a nonprofit, raised $22 million to launch an autonomous floating trash collector in the Pacific in September 2018, but it collapsed in December. Founder Boyan Slat recently presented a sturdier version but said more development is needed to make the project economically sustainable.

Plastic Spillover

Plastic waste is rising world-wide, with rivers in countries lacking waste-management leaking massive amounts into the oceans.

Largest polluting rivers, in thousands

of metric tons a year, 2005-14

Largest polluters by percentage of total municipal plastic waste*

2060 projected

Yangtze

Ganges

Brazil

Huangpu

Indonesia

Philippines

Germany

Nigeria,

Cameroon

India,

Bangladesh

Russia

Largest polluting rivers, in thousands

of metric tons a year, 2005-14

Largest polluters by percentage of total municipal plastic waste*

2060 projected

Yangtze

Brazil

India,

Bangladesh

Ganges

Indonesia

Philippines

Germany

Huangpu

Nigeria,

Cameroon

Russia

Largest polluting rivers, in thousands

of metric tons a year, 2005-14

Largest polluters by percentage of total municipal plastic waste*

2060 projected

Yangtze

Huangpu

Ganges

Brazil

Indonesia

Philippines

Germany

Nigeria,

Cameroon

India,

Bangladesh

Russia

Largest polluters by percentage of total municipal plastic waste*

2060 projected

Brazil

Indonesia

Philippines

Germany

Russia

Largest polluting rivers, in thousands

of metric tons a year, 2005-14

Yangtze

Huangpu

Ganges

Nigeria,

Cameroon

India,

Bangladesh

*Lower estimates; out of 188 countries

Sources: ‘Future scenarios of global plastic waste generation and disposal’ Laurent Lebreton, Anthony Andrady (polluters); ‘River plastic emissions to the world’s oceans’ Laurent C. M. Lebreton, Joost van der Zwet, Jan-Willem Damsteeg, Boyan Slat, Anthony Andrady & Julia Reisser (rivers)

Overuse of plastics is the bigger problem, say environmentalists. Global plastics production has nearly doubled to some 350 million metric tons annually since 2002 and is forecast to triple by 2050, according to industry association PlasticsEurope and the Ellen MacArthur Foundation.

“We’re never going to recycle our way out of this plastic crisis,” said Kevin Stairs, a chemicals and pollution expert at Greenpeace. Recycling makes people think there is a solution but, he added, “that’s simply not the case.”

Yet companies keep launching recycling initiatives, partly to meet consumer demand for more sustainable products and to bolster corporate-responsibility credentials. Adidas AG in 2015 unveiled a sneaker made partially from fishing nets recycled into nylon thread. Making 50 prototype pairs highlighted difficulties.

‘People feel good they are contributing to something,’ said Alexander Taylor, who designed the Adidas sneaker using fishing nets. Photo: michaela rehle/Reuters

Adidas now has more than 450 products—from Manchester United jerseys to jackets—that it labels “ocean plastic.” But unlike its initial sneakers, these aren’t made of trash fished from the seas. Adidas instead uses plastics collected from coastal areas.

“We were looking for raw-material sources that could supply much larger quantities,” said spokesman Stefan Pursche, adding that collecting plastic waste from beaches presented a more reliable option.

The switch highlights another obstacle to cleaning oceans: Abundant recycling-ready plastic on land diminishes incentives to fish for it. Instead, many companies are intercepting it at the shore.

“Plastic in the ocean at some point needs to be tackled, but at this point it’s about turning the tap off,” said Oliver Campbell, Dell Technologies Inc. ’s packaging and procurement director.

Since 2017 Dell has recycled 27 metric tons of ocean-bound plastic collected within 50 kilometers, or roughly 30 miles, of coastlines or waterways in the developing world. The company reuses the material for packaging and is expanding the initiative.

HP Inc. says it sourced 450 metric tons of trash at risk of reaching the sea in Haiti, equivalent to 35 million plastic bottles, to make ink cartridges and parts of laptops and monitors.

A Unifi employee moves a tube to sort recycled plastic-bottle chips at the Repreve bottle-processing center in Yadkinville, N.C. Photo: Chuck Burton/Associated Press

The tech companies, together with General Motors Co. , Interface and others, have forged partnerships under the two-year-old NextWave Plastics consortium to commercialize supply chains that prevent plastic from reaching oceans.

Mr. Campbell says the cost of ocean-bound plastics is similar to using other recycled materials and declining.

Unifi, which already produces polyester yarns from plastic bottles, recently unveiled a new fiber made from ocean-bound plastics. The supply chain is expensive and complicated but Mr. Carey said the company “listened to our customers and found an opportunity.”

“ ‘We’re never going to recycle our way out of this plastic crisis.’ ”

—Kevin Stairs, an expert at Greenpeace

Several initiatives are paying fishermen and coastal communities to collect marine litter. Companies behind the efforts say they provide financial opportunities, raise consumer awareness and boost brands.

“People feel good they are contributing to something,” said Alexander Taylor, who designed the Adidas sneaker using fishing nets.

Interface’s Net-Works program, launched in 2012 to collect abandoned fishing nets in the Philippines, expanded to more than 40 locations, including in Cameroon. The project has recovered some 240 metric tons of fishing nets and supports the livelihood of 2,200 families.

Coca-Cola in October introduced its first plastic bottle made with 25% recycled marine litter. An initial run of 300 bottles shows chemical recycling can make damaged ocean-plastics reusable, the company said.

“The more we create the demand for these materials, the more people will be incentivized,” said Bruno van Gompel, Coca-Cola’s Western Europe supply-chain director. “Even cleaning up beaches and the sea will become a new type of economy.”

SHARE YOUR THOUGHTS

How can discarded plastic be reused in a way that addresses the overuse of the material? Join the conversation below.

Write to Emre Peker at emre.peker@wsj.com

Copyright ©2019 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8